Leonard Wood Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Leonard Wood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ft. Leonard Wood courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Question Of The day

who's talking here?

Erin 2
Stori 2
Colonel Angus 5
Beth 2
Jules 2
SemperFi Girl 2
ItsBetterUDontKnow 5
Just Laura 2
AudreyKeg 4
RikkiJo 1
Zombie Kitten 5
Leee 5
alanna 1
Dochoward 1
Nicholette 2
Taren 2
SassieLady 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

SemperFi Girl --- 15 years ago -

Is is something that got me thinking, based on another thread on here. So here is the "Question of the Day", lol.
Do you think housing should separate where people live based on rank? Example, should an E4 family be living next to an E7 family per say? Happy discussing! 

Erin (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

You are opening a can of worms...lol.

My opinion is that people should be able to coexist in the same housing area, hell, we have for 3 years. If a family is getting out of hand ie...partying, loud music, causing problems...they should get two warnings from housing and then be evicted. JMO 

Zombie Kitten --- 15 years ago -

The only thing that bothers me about that is the difference in BAH. There is a pretty good difference in BAH when it comes to an e4 vs e7.

I have no issue with say an e6(and up) living next to a 1LT or a 2LT because the BAH rate is pretty close.

I get really irked thinking about how people live near me, but pay $300 less for the same crappy house. Or even better, when an e4 can have a nice renovated house, but we get to pay $300 more a month for an unrenovated, smaller house. I understand that having more kids means you need a bigger house... but that doesn't mean I have to like it. :) They should seperate neighborhoods based on rates of BAH. An e4 definately wouldn't end up next to an e7 or e8, or an O, so I guess that would segregate ranks a little bit. 

Zombie Kitten --- 15 years ago -

Oh, and I really like how in other places, neighborhoods have a set "rent" ammount. I have a friend who's husband is navy, and they live in housing, but they get a little over $300/mo back each month. 

Dochoward --- 15 years ago -

I don't think housing should be based on your BAH not rank.. Then at least everyone is paying the same amount for the same crappy housing! You really cannot compare this housing to other post housing.. It seems like they just want to fill in the empty blanks and not really have a system. I was under the impression that it was suppose to run like a rental office but it doesn't. 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I don't care who lives next to who ... but I agree w/ ZK .... we shouldn't have been paying our full BAH for an 850 sq ft house, when someone else was paying the same for a 2400 sq ft house.

but, that is why we chose to move off post. yes, living ON post was about $200/month cheaper, but at least now I can't complain about my house, because I chose it, not balfour beatty. :) 

Leee --- 15 years ago -

Quiet time is 2300 screw that! It is throat punching tempting when I'm trying to sleep or the kids, and our pictures are rattling on the wall because the neighbors want to bbq with their music blasting. 

Leee --- 15 years ago -

Granted they are "lower enlisted" but I'm not discriminating. Although, last post separated rank housing and I loved my quiet neighborhood.;) 

Just Laura --- 15 years ago -

They should seperate neighborhoods based on rates of BAH.

Amen to that! That is why we are moving off post! 

AudreyKeg --- 15 years ago -

Granted they are "lower enlisted"

I would say "junior enlisted" not "lower"

I agree that neighborhoods should be broken up into BAH or rank because of the cost. In Hawaii if you live in an old house then you only pay 80% of your BAH !! I wish that was the case here. In Ft Irwin my parents E-9 lived next to a specilist !! That was really really unfair. 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

don't worry ya'll ... us "lower enlisted" families don't want to live next to you "I'm better than everyone else" higher ranks anymore than you want to live by us. jussayin ;) 

Leee --- 15 years ago -

Ok junior enlisted. Sorry.

I could care less about the rank, just the maturity and respect. I always say you aren't living in the hood anymore. This is a family neighborhood. 

Zombie Kitten --- 15 years ago -

They can't interview people to see where they should live.. and I've known junior enlisted who have been way WAY more mature than senior enlisted, as well as officers... this goes for spouses, too. JUST SAYIN! (I hate that phrase.. just sayin) lol 

RikkiJo --- 15 years ago -

I couldn't agree more, Zombie. That is why we chose to rent off post. I didn't want to pay $1200 for a small 2 bedroom when we could pay the same (or less) for a 4 bedroom that is twice the square footage.
I don't care who I live by when it comes to rank. 

SassieLady --- 15 years ago -

I think maybe they should do it by rank. I agree with Zombie...why should an E2 who has been in for 2 years get the same house as my husband who is an E5 and been in for 7 years (almost). just sayyyyyin'

at Cherry Point if you lived in a 'non staff' neighborhood and then picked up staff you could request a move to a staff and up neighborhood. I think sgt was the highest in our neighborhood and to US it was kinda annoying that here we are 25 and our neighbors are 20 year olds having parties drinking late at night and my 'old man' has to go out there and set them straight. 

SassieLady --- 15 years ago -

JUST SAYIN! (I hate that phrase.. just sayin) lol
RikkiJo --- 6 min ago - quote - hide comments


i totally didn't even see you say that lol 

Nicholette --- 15 years ago -

I believe it should be based on BAH and rank kind of. At Camp Lejeune an E5 with no kids rated a 3 bed/2 bath new home. Here, we rate whatever old 2 bed home they give us. It's been tough adjusting here and thinking we give them all our BAH for this little place and someone else is paying the same for a brand new home. Once our house sells in NC we are thinking about moving off base.

Oh and I have no clue what ranks my neighbors are...we live in Piney Hills and were told this was E6-E9 and Officer housing. So, I am assuming they are all that rank. We've been here just over 2 weeks and have barely even seen any of our neighbors. :/ I kinda wish someone would come outside so I could introduce myself to them! LoL! 

Zombie Kitten --- 15 years ago -

Nicholette, Piney Hills is all kinds of ranks now. I think for the most part, your area of PH is e6 and up,and officers. Over on my side, there are e4-e6, an e7 just got the house across the street, but it's a HUGE renovated house.. I think there is an officer that got a huge reno just down the street from me... then further up Piney HIlls street, there are the higher ranking officers and stuff. Theres no rhyme or reason. 

Stori --- 15 years ago -

I dont care too much about rank in housing areas, I feel that they should be standard rent. Like we live in the 4 bed renos, all 4 bed renos should be X amount a month, all 3 beds x amount a month ETC. get what I mean? Instead of your rank bah. My neighbor is a E3 and my husband an E5 and we live in the same house, but she pays less, to me that is bullpoop 

Beth --- 15 years ago -

I think the breaking it up by rank is the stupidest thing I've heard. The only exception I have to that is enlisted vs officer. Personally I don't care what your rank is, but as an example I don't want to have to watch my every single move for fear the captain next door will be offended and make problems for my husband. So while I say I hate having it divided by rank I get the whole officer/enlisted separated thing. Rank has nothing to do with maturity though.

I do think they should have a set rate for the homes you live in, but then I don't think anyone should get money back just because they live in a lesser home. Point is nothing will ever be fair or good enough for anyone. Someone will always find something to *itch about. (ie: the temp fix for "child care" at DFC.) 

Zombie Kitten --- 15 years ago -

Im curious how there would be a set rate, but no one would get money back? If they literally designated homes for certain ranks, homes would set empty while people waited for the house that corresponds with their rank to open up. Alot of the "e1-e4" houses are a heck of alot nicer than mine, and my husband is e6. 

Beth --- 15 years ago -

I know there's no real way to do that, but it would be nice. 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I like the idea of paying a % of bah for certain houses. crappy old 2 bedrooms, pay 65%, renovated 2 bedroom 70%, old 3 bedroom, 75%, reno 3 bedroom 80%, and if it's a new house (eagle point, the nice officer houses) or a reno 4 bedroom, then 100% ... not that exactly, but you know what I mean.

I think we can all agree that the housing overall here is kinda crappy. Regardless of rank, there should NOT be that much of a difference between the worst house, a decent house, a good house, and an awesome house. Many of the houses are TOO SMALL! Just ridiculously small. In a few more years though, I think it will be a lot better. 

Colonel Angus --- 15 years ago -

i hate my renovated 4 bedroom. i got the dumb bump out one. i shouldn't have to pay the same as someone who gets the much bigger double unit. we can all b*tch til we're blue in the face though. i don't see much being done about it. 

Just Laura --- 15 years ago -

When people choose to live off post to get better housing, they will start to take notice and maybe offer incentives to live on post. We are looking for houses in Lebanon because you can get so much more house for your money there. I am so freakin excited to buy our own house! 

Stori --- 15 years ago -

Yep we are pcsing to gordon in 20 days (yay outta here!) but anyways the houses there look like poo, so we are going to live off post and get twice the bang for our buck. 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

We are looking for houses in Lebanon because you can get so much more house for your money there.

I love living in Lebanon. I love our house and huge yard ... I'm happy with it. There are pros and cons to living anywhere, but for us, the pros outweighed the cons.
i hate my renovated 4 bedroom. i got the dumb bump out one. i shouldn't have to pay the same as someone who gets the much bigger double unit. we can all b*tch til we're blue in the face though. i don't see much being done about it.

I don't even know what you're talking about ... I thought all the 4 bedrooms were the big double units 

Taren --- 15 years ago -

I love how everyone connects lower rank to lower class of being. Not the case. I understand that it stinks to get the same house as an E-4 or lower being that your BAH is more if your husband is higher ranked. The easiest way of solving that dilemma would be for housing to pay you back each month the difference of the lower rank and your husbands rank pay. But I think people should be able to live together peacefully regardless of rank. My husband's E-3 status doesn't make him less of a moral/responsible adult. Heaven for bid he become tired of making a living for what he went to school for originally and decide to change his career near his 30s by joining the army later in life than most enlisted people. It doesn't give people a right to wish he live on the other side of post because they automatically assume that he is going to party all night long with the radio up. 

SemperFi Girl --- 15 years ago -

Okay my turn...I 100% agree with ZK's first post! Couldn't have said it better myself.

Taren, with all do respect I don't think anyone is saying that junior enlisted are lower class people and I do think that it doesn't matter if your husband is an E-4 or an O6 everyone should warrent the same respect. 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

Taren my hubby did the same thing. We are probably older than most everyone on our street have older kids yet are one of the lowest ranking. However we do not party and act like jack@sses like I have seen alot of those who outrank my hubs.

Do I think my house is ugly. Yeah. Do I wish we had been given a 4 bedroom instead of the 3? Yes. But, I also feel like with rank comes privledge (nicer housing). I think that rank should count for something. I dislike that there seems to be no guidelines that are followed. I don't think a house should be given out simply because it is empty. If you have 3 kids you should not get a 6 bedroom. So if you are an e6 and given a crappy house you should not have to pay the full bah. I know that is how they pay for improvements but, come on this housing is not worth what an e4 gets, let alone an e6. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Leonard Wood Underground