Leonard Wood Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Leonard Wood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ft. Leonard Wood courtesy of Military Real Estate!

judging others

who's talking here?

Erin 2
Jules 6
Garbage Vulture 1
ItsBetterUDontKnow 3
Joanna 1
Mitch 5
punkn 1
randifm 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

What does that even me? how is it different than just having an opinion?

If I see someone screaming at their kids, and I say "she shouldn't scream at her kids" ... am I being judgemental, or am I just having an opinion of how I think kids should or shouldn't be treated? Since it's a popular "opinion" few people would think I'm judgemental.

but if I say "women who get abortions are murdering their baby" ... that's controversial, so I'm judgemental?

Isn't it judgemental & hypocritical to say "you're being judgemental for thinking what that person is doing is wrong" ... either way, it's just an opinion, right?

Anybody able to clarify this for me? I'm so sick of people throwing around the phrase "don't be so judgemental" "who are you to judge someone else" blahblahblah 

Erin (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I think judging someone is usually a first time impression. You judge someone on the clothes they wear when you see them, you judge someone on what they look like or how they act. I think that if you meet someone and then get to know them, you are less likely to judge. I try very hard not to judge people and give everyone a chance. I know that first impressions are sometimes not the only impression a person should be known or judged for. 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

okay, so basically ... whether it's a judgement or an opinion could be how much of the "whole story" you know? like, maybe I've never seen that woman before, and who knows what she's going through ... her husbands deployed, her car wouldn't start, her kids colored on the wall with permanent marker ... and she just kinda lost it ... soo, it'd be "judgemental" to think she shouldn't be screaming at her kids?


if someones firm belief that gay marriage should not be legal, because from their personal background and beliefs say that homosexuality is a sin ... are they judgemental, or just firm in their beliefs and have a strong opinion?


like I said, I really don't know what the difference is, and I'm sick of hearing people throw around the word judgemental lol 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

personally, I think when someone says "don't be judgemental" ... they are basically saying "don't have an opinion" ...

which, like I said, is hypocritical. if having an opinion means you're judgemental, and someone else has the opinion that you shouldn't be judgemental ... isn't that person being judgemental of the person being judgemental/having an opinion? 

randifm --- 15 years ago -

I agree that having an opinion comes off as being judgmental, but I like to think there very different. And I think the difference is different for everyone. I like to think that if i look at someone and see what there wearing and make a mental judgment is being judgmental, everything else is my opinion that I'm entitled too lol 

Erin (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I guess I see my opinion on something and being judgemental completely different. But that is just my opinion...teehee ;o) 

Garbage Vulture --- 15 years ago -

An opinion is a simple "feeling" about something. EX I like Miller Light. Being Judgemental is a "Harsh" opinion. EX People who do not like Miller Light are Complete Idiots and should be shot in the face. The problem here is that some use the word Judgemental in place of Opinion. They are not interchangable one is "more" than the other. Its like saying "My toothache is 'killing' me" Really, how many people have died from a toothache? 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

I think some 30 year old guy just died from a toothache. ( it got infected) He didn't have health insurance which is why in my opinion we need Universal health care. Maybe I'm being judgmental but, people that complain we don't need universal health care either have health insurance or they are bloody idiots. 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

and my hubs agrees with you on your assessment of people who don't like Miller Light. 

Mitch --- 15 years ago -

I think people who are from America, and use the term "bloody" to describe something not literally covered in blood, are obsessed with europe. 

Mitch --- 15 years ago -

Wait, I forgot the :P thing. 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

You would be correct in your judgement of me, lol. 

Mitch --- 15 years ago -

So, judging isn't always negative. 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

In my opinion it isn't negative if the judgement is positive :) 

Joanna --- 15 years ago -

people who are from America, and use the term "bloody" to describe something not literally covered in blood, are obsessed with europe.
maybe you just watch too much of Harry Potter movies :P 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

Of course you can judge someone negatively and be totally correct. Like saying my sister in law is a piece of trash would be a correct appraisal of her character, lol. 

Mitch --- 15 years ago -

Yes, yes it is. See, it's only natural to judge. Who gives a flying flip? The people who sit there and say "Don't judge, it's not ok to judge.. " and all that crap are probably more judgemental than the person they are lecturing. I could give a flying flip who judges what and how and if they are right or wrong... so does that make me NOT judgemental? 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

We are all judgmental in our own ways because we are all different. 

Mitch --- 15 years ago -

You are calling me "different". I'm highly offended. 

punkn --- 15 years ago -

When condemnation comes after opinion then it becomes judgement 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Leonard Wood Underground