Leonard Wood Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Leonard Wood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ft. Leonard Wood courtesy of Remilitary.com!

opinion needed ...who should pay?

who's talking here?

Garbage Vulture 2
ItsBetterUDontKnow 1
CHem bur lee 4
Sadie 3
Mitch 2
LostInTheWoods 1
randifm 1
Marletha Lequita 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

CHem bur lee --- 15 years ago -

So a boyfriend lent his girlfriends car to his sister on a Saturday... the sister picks up the car...after driving about the 30miles the brother says make sure u check the oil cuz it leaks.. sister checks oil ads a hurt fills with gas and adds water too. Driver the car about 30 more miles no problem.. then leaves to drive the car about 100 miles but checks oil and water first all is fine nothing added but gas...

Makes it all the way then drives the car for no more than 5 miles a day for 3 days...

Brother calls and says we need the car back cuz another car broke down...

Sister and husband check the fluids so it can be driven a 100 miles back to brother and girlfriend... ad water and oil.

Sister drives 70 miles car feels warm but temp gauge is normal but pulls over anyway. Once pulled over car starts smoking..temp gauge still normal.. but car wont start gets towed back by sister.

Motor is blown...

Also the car when picked up had multiple lights on the dash:. Engine oil temp almost everything.. the car had a wiring problem too where u had to wiggle it behind the stereo every now and then to get it to start.

So who pays for the motor and installation?

The sister, the girlfriend, the brother, split 50/50 split another way?? 

Marletha Lequita --- 15 years ago -

The owner of the car. 

Sadie --- 15 years ago -

The sister shouldn't of took a car with engine lights on it, the boyfriend shouldn't of loaned out a car that wasn't his. You can visually check the water and oil, you don't need to rely on a gauge especially when its known to have issues. If the overheating and lack of water and oil caused the motor to blow then the sister. If not then the boyfriend and owner. 

CHem bur lee --- 15 years ago -

The boyfriend got permission from the girlfriend..they live together and share everything have for about 3 years...

The only gauge that the sister relied on was the temp gauge everything else was checked often. 

Sadie --- 15 years ago -

I would ask a mechanic what broke the car - its time was up or lack of water and oil. 

Garbage Vulture --- 15 years ago -

Was the cars blue book even worth a new engine? 

randifm --- 15 years ago -

The owner should pay. It obviously had issues and was just a matter of time before it died. I mean usually if it has that many known issues it has that many unknown issues as well. 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

The owner ... Obviously the car wasnt in great shape to start with or the borrower wouldnt have had to keep checking fluids so often 

Sadie --- 15 years ago -

What if driving it 200 miles with low fluid is what did it?

This is the kind of thing that causes family fights. 

LostInTheWoods --- 15 years ago -

I love my family way too much to lend them things I like. ;) It is nice, though, to hear about a family that get along enough to share.

I think the only perspective you can fairly take is that of the owner. If I lent out a car with problems under the hood, I'm not sure I'd reasonably expect someone to pay for anything other than towing. But if it's new damage to the body, that's a different story. But that's just me. 

Garbage Vulture --- 15 years ago -

My guess is that the cost of a new engine would be more than the car was worth in the first place 

Mitch --- 15 years ago -

I love my family way too much to lend them things I like. ;) It is nice, though, to hear about a family that get along enough to share.

I think the only perspective you can fairly take is that of the owner. If I lent out a car with problems under the hood, I'm not sure I'd reasonably expect someone to pay for anything other than towing. But if it's new damage to the body, that's a different story. But that's just me.


That's me, also. Plus, the car sounds like it was probably on its last leg, anyways. 

CHem bur lee --- 15 years ago -

Gv - the cost of the new motor installed will be 1200, unsure of blue book but it was bought for 3000 maybe a year ago

Sadie the car was driven 200 miles with low fluid because the fluids were checked very often.. the longest it drove without being checked was 70 miles all at once 

Mitch --- 15 years ago -

Kimberly, it sounds like you already have your opinion made, and it's not the same opinion as the majority of us.

The owner shouldn't have ok'd lending a car that needed so much care just to be driven, and not expect to have to pay when the damage that was probably inevitable, happened.

What do the people involved want to do? No one wants to pay for it? Each party wants the other to cough up the cash? 

CHem bur lee --- 15 years ago -

Well I am one of the ppl... I borrowed the car because I had absolutely no Ethe option cuz we had our own car troubles... I thought it would be fair to split the cost 50/50 but my husband says I should have to pay and my dad says I should pay it all... I called her and tried to offer that to her..but im waiting for her to call back.. I don't think I should pay even half so if she says no ill prob end up in court with her...

My brother is trying not to be involved simply because they are splitting soon just finishing out there rental agreement.. but this happened way back around memorial day..

I also have my brothers phone bill in my name so he pays me 60 monthly for it since the car thing I told him to wait to pay it..

And I got a free tow throughinsurance and had the car towed to a mechanic we all know 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Leonard Wood Underground